Clear Aligners vs. Fixed Orthodontic Appliances: Effects on Periodontal Health and Plaque Accumulation
Main Article Content
Abstract
Introduction: In order to improve oral function and aesthetic results, orthodontic treatments like fixed orthodontic appliances and clear aligners are frequently utilized. The purpose of this study is to compare how clear aligners and fixed appliances affect gingival health, plaque prevention, and general oral hygiene while undergoing orthodontic treatment.
Methodology: For this research study patients from Khyber College of Dentistry, Peshawar received orthodontic treatment during a 12-month period. The research sample consisted of two groups containing 62 patients who wore clear aligners and another 62 patients with fixed appliances. The study conducted clinical examinations at baseline and then again at months 6 and 12 by measuring PI, GI, PPD, and BOP. The researchers employed both Descriptive Statistics while performing Independent T-Tests for their analysis process.
Results: The clear aligner therapy produced better outcomes regarding plaque index since participants in this group reported a mean score of 0.84 while participants wearing fixed teeth appliances registered a mean plaque index of 1.57 which proved statistically significant at p < 0.05. Aligners yielded better periodontal health scores compared to traditional fixed appliances as patients with aligners exhibited gingival index scores of 0.72 (p < 0.01) while patients with fixed appliances presented scores of 1.39. Research results showed lower probing pocket depth PPD measurements in the aligner group at twelve months (mean PPD = 2.28mm) compared to fixed appliance use (mean PPD = 2.81mm with p < 0.05 significance). The BOP percentage registered at 22.6% in the aligner group showed better results than the fixed appliance group which presented BOP at 53.2% with a statistically significant difference (p < 0.05).
Conclusion: Clear aligners were more advantageous than fixed orthodontic appliances because they reduced plaque formation and improved periodontal health protection. The technology represents an improved solution to preserve oral hygiene together with gingival health during orthodontic treatment. Additional research involving bigger participant samples must be conducted to validate these findings.
Downloads
Article Details
Section
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
References
Oikonomou E, Foros P, Tagkli A, Rahiotis C, Eliades T, Koletsi D. Impact of aligners and fixed appliances on oral health during orthodontic treatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Oral health & preventive dentistry. 2021 Dec 8;19:b2403661.
Pango Madariaga AC, Bucci R, Rongo R, Simeon V, D’Antò V, Valletta R. Impact of fixed orthodontic appliance and clear aligners on the periodontal health: a prospective clinical study. Dentistry journal. 2020 Jan 2;8(1):4.
Shokeen B, Viloria E, Duong E, Rizvi M, Murillo G, Mullen J, Shi B, Dinis M, Li H, Tran NC, Lux R. The impact of fixed orthodontic appliances and clear aligners on the oral microbiome and the association with clinical parameters: a longitudinal comparative study. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics. 2022 May 1;161(5):e475-85.
Partouche AJ, Castro F, Baptista AS, Costa LG, Fernandes JC, Fernandes GV. Effects of multibracket orthodontic treatment versus clear aligners on periodontal health: an integrative review. Dentistry journal. 2022 Sep 21;10(10):177.
Di Spirito F, D’Ambrosio F, Cannatà D, D’Antò V, Giordano F, Martina S. Impact of clear aligners versus fixed appliances on periodontal status of patients undergoing orthodontic treatment: a systematic review of systematic reviews. InHealthcare 2023 May 6 (Vol. 11, No. 9, p. 1340). MDPI.
Tamer İ, Öztaş E, Marşan G. Orthodontic Treatment with Clear Aligners and The Scientific Reality Behind Their Marketing: A Literature Review. Turk J Orthod. 2019 Dec 1;32(4):241-246. doi: 10.5152/TurkJOrthod.2019.18083
Rouzi M, Zhang X, Jiang Q, Long H, Lai W, Li X. Impact of clear aligners on oral health and oral microbiome during orthodontic treatment. international dental journal. 2023 Oct 1;73(5):603-11.
Crego-Ruiz M, Jorba-García A. Assessment of the periodontal health status and gingival recession during orthodontic treatment with clear aligners and fixed appliances: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicina Oral, Patologia Oral Y Cirugia Bucal. 2023 Jan 15;28(4):e330.
Partouche AJD, Castro F, Baptista AS, Costa LG, Fernandes JCH, Fernandes GVO. Effects of Multibracket Orthodontic Treatment versus Clear Aligners on Periodontal Health: An Integrative Review. Dent J (Basel). 2022 Sep 21;10(10):177. doi: 10.3390/dj10100177.
Issa FH, Issa ZH, Rabah AF, Hu L. Periodontal parameters in adult patients with clear aligners orthodontics treatment versus three other types of brackets: A cross-sectional study. Journal of orthodontic science. 2020 Jan 1;9(1):4.
Saengphen T, Koontongkaew S, Utispan K. Effectiveness of a Combined Toothbrushing Technique on Cariogenic Dental Biofilm in Relation to Stainless Steel and Elastomeric Ligatures in Orthodontic Patients: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Healthcare (Basel). 2023 Mar 2;11(5):731. doi: 10.3390/healthcare11050731
Lanteri V, Poggi S, Blasi S, De Angelis D, Gangale S, Farronato M, Maiorani C, Butera A. Periodontal aspects of orthodontic treatment with Invisalign® versus fixed appliances in the same patients: a pilot study. International Journal of Clinical Dentistry. 2020;13(4):419-47.
Elaouame A, Qaderi M, Khamlich K, Zahiri M, Alami S. Effect of Orthodontic Treatments by Dental and Periodontal Health Aligners: A Literature Review. Open Access Library Journal. 2023 Jun 6;10(6):1-0.
Calderon-Augusto M, Flores-Mir C, Arriola-Guillén LE. Reporting sample size calculation in randomized clinical trials published in 4 orthodontic journals. Turkish Journal of Orthodontics. 2021 Dec 1;34(4):214.
Akram S, Zeeshan M, Masood M, Anthoney D, Irshad N, Anwar M. The Impact of Orthodontic fixed appliance and clear plastic aligner in periodontal health; A comparative clinical study. Pakistan Journal of Medical & Health Sciences. 2022 May 13;16(04):305-.
Cenzato N, Marcolongo L, Sanchez S, Maspero CM. Qualitative Microbiological Evaluation of Dental Plaque in Patients with Fixed Appliances and Clear Aligners. Journal Of Biological Regulators & Homeostatic Agents. 2022;36(3):647-53.
Contaldo M, Lucchese A, Lajolo C, Rupe C, Di Stasio D, Romano A, Petruzzi M, Serpico R. The oral microbiota changes in orthodontic patients and effects on oral health: An overview. Journal of clinical medicine. 2021 Feb 16;10(4):780.
Partouche AJ. Effects of Conventional Orthodontic Treatment Versus Transparent Aligners in Periodontal Health: An Integrative Review. PQDT-Global. 2021.
Elkordy SA, Palomo L, Palomo JM, Mostafa YA. Do fixed orthodontic appliances adversely affect the periodontium? A systematic review of systematic reviews. InSeminars in Orthodontics 2019 Jun 1 (Vol. 25, No. 2, pp. 130-157). WB Saunders.
Jones MS. Comparison of Periodontium Among Subjects Treated with Clear Aligners and Conventional Orthodontics (Master's thesis, Creighton University).
Quinzi V, Carli E, Mummolo A, De Benedictis F, Salvati SE, Mampieri G. Fixed and removable orthodontic retainers, effects on periodontal health compared: a systematic review. Journal of Oral Biology and Craniofacial Research. 2023 Mar 1;13(2):337-46.
Marincak Vrankova Z, Rousi M, Cvanova M, Gachova D, Ruzicka F, Hola V, Lochman J, Izakovicova Holla L, Brysova A, Borilova Linhartova P. Effect of fixed orthodontic appliances on gingival status and oral microbiota: a pilot study. BMC Oral Health. 2022 Oct 27;22(1):455. doi: 10.1186/s12903-022-02511-9.
Zhao R, Huang R, Long H, Li Y, Gao M, Lai W. The dynamics of the oral microbiome and oral health among patients receiving clear aligner orthodontic treatment. Oral diseases. 2020 Mar;26(2):473-83.